Over the years I have had numerous discussions about whether or not Telstra is really a good investment. Many investors have continued to hold this stock over the past 11 years, despite its poor performance, mainly because they continue to receive a dividend. However, I believe this is simply justification to make them feel better about holding a share that has averaged an annual loss of 1.51 per cent per annum from 1 January 1998 to 31 December 2008. In fact Telstra has suffered a 67.17 per cent fall from its all-time high of $9.20 in February 1999 to its recent low of $3.02 in April 2009.
In the past 11 years, Telstra has only risen during 6 of those years, while suffering negative returns during the other years. If we include this year, it is currently down 7.83 per cent to 31 July, which means Telstra is a really 50/50 bet. Interestingly, Telstra is not the only stock that has performed poorly over this period. Investors only need to look at the likes of NAB or AMP to see that these solid companies have roughly achieved a 50/50 gain/loss record.
Holding on to a stock simply to receive a dividend can be detrimental to an investor?s portfolio especially when there are many other good stocks that have performed far better and also pay a dividend .The example of Telstra also highlights why buy and hold is not necessarily a good strategy and why using a simple stop loss can effectively minimize any downside risk to a portfolio.
So what can we expect in the market?
Last week the All Ordinaries has risen to its highest level since October 2008, although the market is now displaying signs that the current bull-run is slowing. There is an old saying that what goes up fast usually comes down fast, and the All Ordinaries Index has moved up at a faster rate over the last 5 months, since the low in March 09, than what occurred following the long term low in March 2003. Given this we need to expect the market will fall away very soon, as it cannot keep rising at this pace.
As I mentioned last week, while I don╒t believe the bullish run will last for too much longer, I need to accept that it may move up further into August than anticipated. If the market continues to rise, probability suggests that it will fail to push through my upper target level of 4600 points. When it does fall, it could move down to between 3500 and 3700 points by mid September - how far the market moves down will indicate whether we can expect further falls or whether the next bull-run will commence. As usual only time will tell, but for now make sure you set stop losses so as to protect your capital.